why they brokeup

[i<3S.C.8&Jake Gyllenhall&McFlY]

does anyone actually know why they broke-up?Was it because of sales or did they decide themselves???

[Dylan]

This is just my opinion BTW

IMO they broke up partly because of I Dream - let's be honest it was not a success (sadly ) and because of the not-so-good chart entry of Dreaming (number 19 in the UK chart ) man they did fall. Also partly because they'd already lost a lot of fans when I Dream began - they liked S Club 8 but didn't like the whole I Dream thing so I guess people just stopped supporting them.

It was also because the Clubbers didn't really enjoy being a band anymore - it was said that some of them thought it was 'uncool' to be in a pop band but I'm not sure how true that last part is.

[i<3S.C.8&Jake Gyllenhall&McFlY]

thanks !

[gemma]

I think if they had done another album but with some really hip, "in" kinda songs they would have gone back up atleast a bit.

[Dylan]

hihi said:

I think if they had done another album but with some really hip, "in" kinda songs they would have gone back up atleast a bit.

Yeah they would

[angelD]

well rochelle is asshamed of sclub8 but stacey is proud of them

i think i dream songs were more rnb/ musical sounding to their usual sound .

[speakers]

candyangel said:

well rochelle is asshamed of sclub8 but stacey is proud of them

i think i dream songs were more rnb/ musical sounding to their usual sound .

where'd you hear that?
I wont lie, the idream album sin't that good,
but like i said, if they made another album with the type of songs they wanted to do, it wouldve been better,
then they'd have more fans and people would enjoy idream
i know i did at least

[jessinsomniatic]

I think it was because of Idream
I've always been convinced that was the reason
thats why I was never a big fan of the rest of the cast that weren't in SC8
I'm not bashing them
I just wasnt their biggest fan.

[[ Gummiebearz ♥ ]]

lol yeah i think it was mainly due to i dream as it wasn't as popular as they hoped it would be
yeah i've heard that rochelle is ashamed to have been in the band... forget where i heard it from but i'm pretty sure she's said it at least once

[i<3S.C.8&Jake Gyllenhall&McFlY]

rochelle was embarrased!? i loves s club 8 and was a huge fan too! Yeah i thought it was because because of idream!xxxxx

[Team Danny Jones.]

that's sad.

[rosey]

rochelle's ashamed of s club 8?
hmm i read somewhere else that it was also cos they were getting older?
and idream didn't do well...

[Efforts]

I think it wasn't really because of they were ashamed. I think it was because of the ratings of I Dream and the fans.

But I dont think Rochelle was really ashamed. If we have any proof of anyone being kinda ashamed it's Aaron. I remember reading in a magazine scan about some of their secrets that Aaron once denied he was in the band because someone said they were trash. If I was proud of the band I wouldn't have denied it.

[xxonestepcloserxx]

i think the only reason they did i dream was because they were getting unpopular as a band and they wearnt takeing it seriously. did anyone realise watching them perform any of their songs that they looked bored. i also think they should have done some rnb type songs or something in their second album or at liest better songs then the rush for example.
i liked i dream although i could have done with at liest one song where hannah daisy rochelle and stacey solo, unless they attually didnt want to.
i wouldnt have thought that they would have been ashamed with being in the group since they auditioned for it in the first place, but of cause they were loseing popularity.

[mangoly]

I really liked their song dreaming, but I gotta admit their show did fail and they did look bored =/